BREAKING NEWS: Major relief for OINP applicants as Ontario court rules in their favour; Government faces $20,000 costs order
A major development has emerged in the legal battle involving applicants under Ontario's Express Entry: Skilled Trades Stream, with affected applicants claiming a significant victory against the Ontario government.
According to information shared by the applicants, a three-judge panel of the Ontario Divisional Court delivered a majority decision in their favour, with two judges supporting the applicants and one taking a dissenting position. Applicants also say the court ordered the Ontario government to pay $20,000 in costs. However, the full written judgment is needed to confirm the precise terms of the ruling, the scope of relief granted and the applicants covered by the decision.
Background: Why Did Ontario Return the OINP Applications?
The dispute dates back to November 2025, when the Ontario government announced that it was suspending the Express Entry: Skilled Trades Stream under the Ontario Immigrant Nominee Program (OINP) and returning all pending applications.
In its November 14, 2025 announcement, the province cited concerns about systemic fraud and misrepresentation within the stream. The government said its review had identified vulnerabilities in the program that raised questions about the reliability of information submitted by applicants, particularly regarding employment history and eligibility requirements. The province also pointed to its limited allocation of permanent residency nominations from the federal government, saying those nominations needed to be directed towards applicants who could meet Ontario's immediate labour market needs.
However, the decision affected thousands of applicants, including individuals who maintained that they had submitted genuine documents and met all the program's eligibility requirements. Applicants Challenged the Government's Decision The affected applicants questioned why everyone was treated the same way when concerns about fraud and misrepresentation may have involved only certain applications.
They argued that the government should have examined individual applications instead of returning all pending files through a blanket decision. Applicants also raised concerns about not being given an adequate opportunity to explain their circumstances or respond to allegations of irregularities in their applications.
After initially organizing protests against the provincial government's decision, the applicants eventually turned to the courts for relief. In July 2026, approximately 300 affected applicants challenged the government's decision through legal proceedings. The case was heard by a three-judge panel of the Ontario Divisional Court, comprising Justice Nakatsuru, Justice O'Brien and Justice Vermette.
More Than $1 Million Spent on Legal Proceedings, Applicants Say According to information shared by the applicants, five lawyers represented approximately 300 individuals in the legal challenge. Each applicant reportedly paid between $2,500 and $5,000 towards legal expenses, taking the group's total legal costs to more than $1 million.
The applicants also say the immigration uncertainty had serious personal consequences. Approximately 100 affected individuals have reportedly returned to India, while others managed to maintain their immigration status in Canada.
Will the Decision Apply to All 2,680 Affected Applications?
One of the biggest unanswered questions is whether the court's decision will benefit only the approximately 300 applicants involved in the legal challenge or extend to all approximately 2,680 applications returned under the Skilled Trades Stream.
Applicants say this remains unclear, and the full written judgment will be important in determining the scope of the court's decision. If confirmed by the written ruling, the outcome could have significant implications for how Ontario handles immigration applications and the extent to which government decisions affecting large groups of applicants can be challenged through judicial review.
For now, affected applicants will be watching closely for the complete judgment and further clarification from the Ontario government.